Standing Seam Tin Roofs on Historic Charleston Houses: History, Care and BAR Rules

Walk almost any block of the Charleston peninsula and look up. Over the piazzas and dormers you will see roofs laid in long vertical pans with slim raised ribs between them, many painted red or green. Most people call them tin roofs. Many are actually terne, and they are so much a part of the city that the Board of Architectural Review lists standing seam metal as one of the four materials found on most historic roofs in Charleston.

If you own one of these houses, or you are thinking about buying one, the roof is worth understanding. This guide covers where these roofs came from, how true standing seam differs from 5V crimp, how terne is painted and repaired, what the City's preservation rules say about replacement, and what to ask about the roof on an older home.

What a "Tin" Roof Actually Is

The word "tin" has always been loose shorthand. The National Park Service's Preservation Brief 4, Roofing for Historic Buildings, explains that tin plate is sheet iron coated with tin, while terne plate is iron dipped in an alloy of lead and tin, which gives it a duller finish. The brief notes that old records often confuse the two. Washington's historic preservation office puts it plainly in its guidelines for roofs on historic buildings: a terne plate roof is commonly referred to as a "tin" roof, after the principal metal used in its manufacture.

How Metal Roofs Spread in the 1800s

According to Preservation Brief 4, metal roofing was mainly a 19th century development. Once American rolling mills were established, tin became the most common roofing material in the country because it was cheap, light and needed little upkeep, and by the middle of the century sheet metal often replaced tile roofs. The brief points to Thomas Jefferson's standing seam tin roof at Monticello as an early example, and notes that tin roofs were usually painted red, or a green meant to imitate the patina of copper.

In Charleston, metal was often a later layer over an earlier roof. The Simon Jude Chancognie House, built around 1810, is one documented case. When a fire broke out next door on March 14, 1974, a News and Courier account quoted in this history of the Chancognie House reported damage to the attic, "where a cedar shingle roof, under the tin roof, caught fire." On a house of that age, an older roof may still sit beneath the one you see.

Standing Seam, 5V Crimp and Modern Panels

Traditional standing seam

A standing seam roof is made of long metal pans laid with the slope of the roof. The edges of neighboring pans are turned up and folded together into a raised rib, so the joint sits above the water running down the roof. Preservation Brief 4 makes a point that matters on a historic house: seam spacing affects the scale of the building, so replacement work should match the original dimensions.

The City's BAR Policy Statement for Historic Roofing, adopted on December 10, 2014, goes further. It states that all standing seam metal roofs shall be of traditional hand-crimped detailing, and that modern snap-lock or commercial-grade metal roofs are inappropriate and will not be approved.

5V crimp and exposed-fastener panels

5V crimp is a different system. As metal roofing industry veteran Todd Miller explains in his piece on exposed-fastener roofing, 5V crimp is one of the patterns used on exposed-fastener panels, which overlap one another and are installed with screws driven through the panels, leaving the heads exposed. Standing seam products have no exposed fastener heads. Miller notes that the screw washers dry out and crack over time and that fastener holes can wear larger as the metal moves, which lets water in.

The 2024 BAR General Guidelines state that asphalt shingles and V-crimp metal roofing are inappropriate for historic buildings, and clear up a common mix-up in one line: "V-crimp is not the same as standing seam metal."

Flat seam and copper

Flat seam work shows up on porches. The Preservation Society of Charleston's Resilience Guidance for Charleston: Roof System, prepared in July 2024, notes that historic flat metal porch roofs are made of small pieces of copper, seamed and soldered together. Copper is usually left unpainted.

How Long These Roofs Last

In a Journal of Light Construction Q&A, Rob Haddock of the Metal Roof Advisory Council observed that "a lot of terne roofs are a good 100 years old," and that copper and lead roofs can reach 150 or even 170 years. He put modern coated carbon steel and aluminum at 40 to 60 years when installed properly. The condition of its paint, seams and flashing tells you far more than its age.

Maintaining a Terne Roof: Paint, Seams and Flashing

Painting

Paint is what keeps terne going. Preservation Brief 4 explains that iron rusts unless it is painted or plated, and that plating protects only while intact, so iron roofing needs an undercoat and ongoing paint. Haddock likewise says terne must be cleaned and painted periodically. Neither sets a fixed schedule. The DC guidelines note that minor corrosion may be removed by wire brushing and repainting, while extensive pitting may call for replacing sections with the same metal.

Because terne's coating is a lead and tin alloy, and lead pigments were used in American exterior coatings until 1978, scraping an old roof is lead-related work. Our post on lead paint disclosure and renovation rules for pre-1978 Charleston homes explains how that process works.

Seams, patches and solder

The Resilience Guidance recommends repairing isolated punctures or rust, preferably with in-kind material, and refastening or soldering slipped panels and open seams. Preservation Brief 4 warns that caulk and bituminous patches are only very temporary and hard to remove later. It also notes that soldering carries a fire risk from the open flame or overheated wood beneath the metal, which the contractor should discuss with the owner. And it cautions that dissimilar metals in contact, such as copper and iron, cause galvanic corrosion.

Flashing and routine checks

Brief 4 calls flashing failure a major cause of roof deterioration. The Resilience Guidance adds that tar and caulk are temporary fixes and that flashing should last at least as long as the roofing around it. It recommends inspecting roofing every six months before hurricane season, clearing gutters at least twice a year, trimming limbs away from the roof and checking the attic at least once a year, where water staining, a dark patch or a white bloom can signal a leak.

Repair or Replace?

On a historic Charleston house, repair is the starting point. The BAR roofing policy states that no historic roof shall be replaced in its entirety unless it can be documented that the roof is beyond reasonable repair, and that a deteriorated roof must be replaced in kind. Where terne metal is not available, staff may approve aluminum or coated copper as an in-kind replacement. Staff may also approve uncoated standing seam copper in place of standing seam terne, except on Category 1 and Category 2 structures.

The Resilience Guidance suggests considering replacement when more than 20 percent of metal roof sections are rusted or punctured, with new flashing as part of the job. Preservation Brief 4 adds that repair costs multiply as trouble recurs, and repeated repairs can eventually equal the cost of a new roof.

Where slate fits in

Slate is also one of the City's four historic roofing materials, and the BAR roofing policy says synthetic materials such as artificial slate are generally not appropriate. The NPS Preservation Brief 29 on historic slate roofs, by Jeffrey S. Levine, notes that metal flashings and plain steel or galvanized nails often wear out long before the slate itself, recommends copper bib repairs over mastic, and observes that once 20 percent or more of the slates are broken, missing or sliding, replacement is usually less costly than individual repairs.

What the City of Charleston BAR Guidelines Say

The BAR General Guidelines, published in March 2024, list the four historic roof materials as standing seam metal, standing seam copper, terra-cotta tile and slate. They say historic roofs should be repaired wherever possible, with like materials, and define in-kind replacement as new material that matches the existing in type, size, profile and material. They also refer readers to NPS Preservation Briefs 4, 29 and 30.

The guidelines explain that the BAR reviews exterior alterations visible from a public right-of-way, that staff may review repairs and in-kind replacements, and that a permit from Building Inspections is required for any work in the City of Charleston. Owners are encouraged to check with City staff before starting. Our guide to BAR approval for historic Charleston homes walks through that review process.

Questions to Ask About the Roof on an Older Home

When you are buying a historic house, raise these with the seller, your inspector and a roofer who knows historic metal:

  • How old is the roof, and what is it made of? Ask for invoices, permits or BAR approvals that show when it was installed.

  • When was it last painted or coated, and with what? Paint history shows how the metal has been cared for.

  • Has it ever leaked, and where? Look in the attic for staining or white bloom, especially around chimneys.

  • What has been patched, and how? Tar, caulk or mismatched metal patches can point to deferred work.

  • Are there hurricane-rated connectors? The Resilience Guidance explains that these tie rafters to the walls and framing below, that a structural engineer or architect should design the layout, that installation can require removing interior finishes, and that straps can be added during a roof replacement.

  • How does the roof factor into insurance? Ask your insurance agent how roof age, material and condition figure into a quote.

Water that gets past a roof ends up in the framing, so read roof findings alongside the termite report; our post on what a CL-100 wood infestation report covers explains that document. Compare everything with the seller's disclosure, too; our guide to the South Carolina property condition disclosure on an older Charleston home explains how that form works. For coverage, contract or code questions, confirm with your insurance agent, attorney or the City's preservation staff.

FAQ

Is a "tin roof" in Charleston really made of tin?

Usually not entirely. Most historic "tin" roofs are terne plate, sheet metal coated with a lead and tin alloy. True tin plate was also used, and old records often confuse the two.

Can I replace a historic standing seam roof with 5V crimp panels?

On a building under BAR review, the 2024 General Guidelines call V-crimp metal roofing inappropriate for historic buildings, and the roofing policy requires traditional hand-crimped detailing on standing seam roofs. Confirm your property's requirements with City preservation staff.

How often does a terne roof need painting?

Preservation sources say terne needs ongoing paint but do not set a single interval. A contractor experienced with historic metal can assess your roof and recommend a schedule.

Does an old metal roof mean the house needs a new roof?

Not necessarily. Many terne roofs have lasted around a century with care, and the City's policy starts from repair.

Conclusion

Standing seam metal roofs are part of what makes a Charleston roofline look the way it does, and they can serve a house for a very long time when the paint is kept up, the seams stay tight and the flashing is sound. The City's rules favor repair and in-kind replacement, so it pays to work with roofers who know the traditional details.

If you are thinking about a historic home, browse our neighborhood guides, take a look at our current listings, or reach out to our team to talk through the houses and blocks you have in mind.

Previous
Previous

The Charleston Joggling Board: History, Makers, Care and Piazza Fit

Next
Next

Holiday Festival of Lights 2026: Charleston's James Island Light Show Guide